Can someone please explain to me why it’s impossible to go to a small church without having to sit through some housewife murdering a Rich Mullins song on Church Karaoke? This has to be my numero uno pet peeve in small churches.
It’s cute when the kids do it. Or if it’s a couple of fourteen year old girls with rehearsed dance moves, then okay. I can live with that. That might even be entertaining, but the inevitable 40-something who hasn’t done a solo since high school- completely unacceptable. It always sounds bad.
Some of you reading this may have participated in Church Karaoke. Repent! Here is a simple rule. Unless you are actually a GIFTED singer, do not do a solo. And just because some of your friends have said that you sound nice, that is not good enough. They are most likely lying. I’m sure William Hung, the Asian guy who brutalized Ricky Martin’s “She Bangs” on American Idol, had plenty of people telling him he sung like a heavenly bird, but the fact is he was probably one of the worst song killers of all time. (Note: I actually like William Hung. He seems like a super nice guy, but he can’t sing.)
There is a chance that you actually can sing, but this needs to be verified before you perform in public. You might want to try recording yourself and then playing it back. If it sounds horrible, do not make the common mistake of thinking it’s just a bad recording. Bad recording or not, that is how it’s going to sound piped through your church’s sound system.
I love to sing. I sing in the shower. I sing to my little boy every night, and he gets a big kick out of it, but I have no delusions of grandeur. It’s just that my little boy isn’t picky. And he probably thinks that I’m just talking funny.
Singing to and about Jesus is a mighty fine thing to do. I encourage everybody to do it, but a solo in church is supposed to inspire the congregation. If you discover a beautiful Casting Crowns song that moves you deeply, you may want to share the song with your fellow worshipers. Okay, but unless you sing better than Mark Hall, just play them the song as it is recorded on their album.
But even then, you may discover it doesn’t take hold of them the way it does to you while you’re driving in your car. I’m not sure why this happens, but it does. I once went to a very small church in a little town where they simply sang along to songs being played on a portable CD player. They had done this for a few songs and then a woman got up and gave a little speech about how a particular song had touched her. She was emotional. She put the song on and watched in horror as we all sat there, virtually unmoved by the song. It was a train wreck. The song was good, but good music has a lot to do with environment. That’s why there’’s a lot of flashy lighting at a concert, and a concert at night or in a dark auditorium is probably much better than the exact same performance in broad daylight. If you’re stuck in traffic and your favorite song comes on the radio, you can crank up the volume and sing along as the world around you fades and the physical act of driving goes into autopilot. That’s a completely different experience than playing the same exact song in church as people sit there in the pews.
Here’s a few pointers to quality musical performances in church:
1. Know the limitations of both the sound system and the performers. If you have a singer who sounds like Celine Dion, but comes out through the speakers sounding more like C3PO, then maybe it’s better not to have people sing through the mics at all. And if you’ve got a rocking sound system and a person who sounds like Mr. Hung wants to do the dreaded karaoke jam, it may be better, as gently as possible, to refuse the offer. Even if a church’s resources and musical talent are quite limited, it still has to do the best it can. But doing the best it can may include not doing some things it’s particularly bad at.
2. Know your strengths. If you can get a choir together and make that sound good singing the classic hymnals, then do that. If you want to do the Casting Crowns song, but do not have a band, maybe a guitar or piano player can learn the song to accompany a soloist.
3. Work on the lighting. Dimming the lights in the sanctuary and lighting the stage can completely change the mood of a performance.
4. People need to praise the Lord with their fellow believers, so get it done somehow.
-Joseph Mazerac